Apple MacBook Air (15″, M3) vs ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507 – Vivobook for Heavy Work, MacBook Air for Everyday Use

    Windows is finally catching up to Apple, or are they? 2024 is the year where we get a massive shakeup in the market, with the new Snapdragon X-series laptops popping up, which deliver ARM-based SoCs to laptops, in order to utilize the low-power performance and efficiency that the technology offers.

    Still, though, Apple has been in on the ARM game for a lot longer (the M1 was revealed back in 2020), so we can’t expect the Snapdragon laptops to perform just as well right out of the gate. However, that won’t stop us from comparing two very similar laptops, that are priced rather evenly and can give you a pretty good laptop experience. Today we’re comparing the 15-inch Apple MacBook Air, which is powered by the M3 SoC, to the brand new ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED, a laptop carrying the much coveted Snapdragon X Elite.

    Apple MacBook Air (M3) 15″: Full Specs / In-depth Review

    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507: Full Specs / In-depth Review

    Apple MacBook Air (M3) 15″ configurations:

    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507 configurations:

    Specs table

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507
    Operating SystemMac OS XWindows 11
    ProcessorApple M3 (8-core CPU)Qualcomm Snapdragon X Elite X1E-78-100
    Qualcomm Snapdragon X Plus X1P-64-100
    GPUApple M3 GPU (10-core)Qualcomm Snapdragon X Elite Adreno GPU
    Display15.3”, (2880 x 1864), IPS15.6″, 3K WQHD+ (2880×1620), 120Hz, OLED
    Memoryup to 24GB Unified Memoryup to 32GB LPDDR5X
    Storageup to 2000GB SSDup to 1000GB SSD
    Battery66Wh70Wh
    Weight3.3 lbs (1.51 kg)3.1 lbs (1.42 kg)
    Dimensions13.40″ x 9.35″ x 0.45″
    (340.4 x 237.6 x 11.5 mm)
    13.88″ x 8.93″ x 0.58″ ~ 0.63″
    (352.6 x 226.9 x 14.7 – 15.9 mm)
    Ports
    • 2x USB Type-C 4.0 ports with Power Delivery, DisplayPort
    • 1x 3.5 mm audio jack
      • 2x USB Type-A 3.2 Gen 1 (5 Gbps)
      • 2x USB Type-C 4.0, Power Delivery (PD), DisplayPort
      • HDMI 2.1
      • MicroSD card reader
      • Wi-Fi: 802.11be
      • Bluetooth 5.4
      • 3.5 mm combo jack

    Unboxing

    Apple bundles a 35W MagSafe charger, however, you can also buy a 70W adapter, if fast charging matters to you. The Vivobook gets a faster 90W Type-C charger and some regions even get a wired ASUS mouse and a 3-in-1 backpack to carry your Vivobook with you.

    Apple MacBook Air (M3) 15″ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507
    Charger power35W90W

    Apple MacBook Air (M3) 15″
    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507

    Design and Construction

    Both laptops are built really well, with metal all around. The Vivobook is around 100 grams lighter, but the MacBook Air is close to 5 mm thinner. Style-wise, MacBooks will always draw attention, especially with the Midnight color that we purchased.

     

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507
    Weight3.3 lbs (1.51 kg)3.1 lbs (1.42 kg)
    Dimensions13.40″ x 9.35″ x 0.45″
    (340.4 x 237.6 x 11.5 mm)
    13.88″ x 8.93″ x 0.58″ ~ 0.63″
    (352.6 x 226.9 x 14.7 – 15.9 mm)

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)
    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507

    Keyboard and touchpad

    The keyboard on a MacBook has a fingerprint reader in the power button, while the layout is the exact same as the board on the 13-inch version. This leaves a lot of unused space on the base. Despite that, typing on the board is very comfortable. There isn’t much key travel, but the feedback is tactile.

    The Vivobook utilizes all the available space, with a full-sized keyboard and a Numpad. Key travel is long, while the feedback is a tad soft but still plenty comfortable. The touchpads are big and smooth, with superb accuracy. Overall, typing and gliding are the last things you need to worry about with these two laptops.

    Apple MacBook Air (M3) 15″
    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507

    Ports

    The Vivobook has a much wider port selection, providing you with a MicroSD card reader, an HDMI port, and two Type-A ports, in addition to the two Type-C ports.

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507
    Ports
    • – 2x USB Type-C 4.0 ports with Power Delivery, DisplayPort
    • – 1x 3.5 mm audio jack
    • – 2x USB Type-A 3.2 Gen 1 (5 Gbps)
    • – 2x USB Type-C 4.0, Power Delivery (PD), DisplayPort
    • – HDMI 2.1
    • – MicroSD card reader
    • – Wi-Fi: 802.11be
    • – Bluetooth 5.4
    • – 3.5 mm combo jack

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)
    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507

    Display and sound quality

    Both laptops come with super sharp panels that give you a very detailed image. In terms of the panels themselves, the IPS screen on the MacBook Air has a slightly higher pixel density and is a lot taller. The Vivobook brings an OLED panel, with deeper blacks and overall vibrant and sharper colors that pop.

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507
    Resolution2880 x 18642880 x 1620
    Aspect ratio14:916:9
    Panel technologyLiquid Retina (basically IPS)OLED
    Pixel density224 PPI212 PPI
    Dot pitch0.11 x 0.11 mm0.12 x 0.12 mm
    Retina distance15.35″ (39 cm)15.74″ (40 cm)

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)
    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507

    Both displays have excellent viewing angles. You can check our video tests down below.

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)
    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507

    The screen of the MacBook is a lot brighter while staying within the appropriate range of uniformity (6%).

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507
    Peak brightness (middle of the screen/average for the entire display area)507/498 nits390/387 nits
    Max deviation6%2%
    Color temperature (on white screen)6680K6530K
    Contrast ratio1360:11 000 000:1

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)
    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507

    Color coverage

    Here are some illustrations (Fig. 1) & (Fig. 2). The whole “sail-shaped” map below consists of all the colors we can see, while the black crooked line shows all the colors from real-world scenes and nature around us.

    Then, we’ve drawn some of the most important and interesting color spaces, compared to the colors that the panels of the laptops can display:

    Standard/For Web: sRGB – widely used color space for most consumer devices, ideal for Web design and development
    For Print: AdobeRGB – used in professional photo editing, graphic design, and print
    For Photographers/Video Editors: DCI-P3 – used in high-end film production, post-production, and digital cinema
    Premium HDR: Rec.2020 – the widest consumer ITU color standard, covering a massive 75.8% of the visible spectrum, a benchmark for premium HDR content

    The yellow dotted line shows the color coverage of the Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″) and the ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507, both of which cover the entire sRGB and DCI-P3 gamuts.

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507
    sRGB100%100%
    DCI-P3100%100%

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)
    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507

    Color accuracy

    Now let’s see how big the difference is between the real colors and the ones you’ll see on the three laptops. We measure that distance in DeltaE – the bigger the number, the more different they look.

    For the next illustration, we’ve chosen 24 common colors like dark and light skin, blue sky, green grass, etc.

    Below you can see the results of the two laptops. Unfortunately, you can’t apply display profiles on Apple devices, so the Vivobook is more accurate with a dE value of 1.3. Still, though, the MacBook Air is accurate enough for Creator work.

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)
    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507

    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507 15.6″ Samsung ATNA56AC03-0 (2880 х 1620) OLED: Buy our profiles

    PWM

    Pulse-width modulation, or PWM for short is when the display flickers fast by constantly shutting on and off, thus appearing more dim. The problem with PWM is that at lower flickering frequencies, your eyes get tired easily. In our tests, the MacBook showed no PWM usage, while the Vivobook uses PWM at all brightness levels. The amplitude of the pulsations is rather small, so the panel is relatively comfortable for prolonged use.

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)
    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507

    Sound

    Both laptops deliver quality audio, with no deviations across the entire frequency range. The speakers are mounted on the bottom

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)
    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507

    Performance – CPU, GPU, Storage

    Below we’ve highlighted the configurations that bought the notebooks with.

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507
    Operating SystemMac OS XWindows 11
    ProcessorApple M3 (8-core CPU)Qualcomm Snapdragon X Elite X1E-78-100
    Qualcomm Snapdragon X Plus X1P-64-100
    GPUApple M3 GPU (10-core)Qualcomm Snapdragon X Elite Adreno GPU

    CPU tests

    The Snapdragon X Elite delivers a 57% higher score in the Cinebench 2024 Multi-core test. However, the MacBook Air is 24% faster in the Single-Core benchmark which is a good indicator for everyday use.

    GPU tests

    The GPU on the MacBook gets a 28% higher score in the 3DMark Wild Life benchmark.

    Battery life

    The MacBook has a slightly smaller battery but delivers an extra hour and 46 minutes of video playback.


    Upgradeability

    The MacBook offers no upgradeability, as both the RAM (Unified Memory) and storage are soldered onto the motherboard. As for the Vivobook, it’s got soldered memory and a single M.2 PCIe slot for Gen 4 SSDs.

    Apple MacBook Air (M3, 15″)
    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507

    Verdict

    The MacBook Air 15 is a fresh new form factor that takes everything that’s great about the 13-inch model and stretches it out to a much more comfortable size for a creator or a designer.

    As for the Vivobook, we’re seeing entirely new “AI-powered” Windows laptops that deliver the efficiency and performance that ARM chips are known for. This gives users a clear alternative to Apple products, albeit, the Snapdragon X Elite platform might need some more work on the software end.

    In terms of efficiency and performance, the Snapdragon X Elite outperforms the M3 SoC for heavy work like 3D Rendering, while the MacBook Air is faster for everyday use, thanks to its 24% higher single-core performance. Also, the GPU of the M3 is more powerful than the Adreno unit in the X Elite. As for battery life, both laptops deliver nicely, but the MacBook lasts longer.

    The displays here are great too, sporting high resolutions, high brightness, and contrast, as well as covering tons of colors that make them prime options for creators. Overall, if you’re already in the Apple ecosystem (aka have an iPhone), the MacBook is the natural choice. The Apple Silicon platform is also a lot more proven and supports more software.

    On the other hand, the Vivobook can only get better with further software support and is upgradeable, so there are definitely some benefits. However, buying it right now might mean having first-hand experience with the troubles of first-gen products, aka new bugs and software compatibility issues. You can check the pricing for both laptops below and make your choice.

    Apple MacBook Air (M3) 15″: Full Specs / In-depth Review

    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507: Full Specs / In-depth Review

    Apple MacBook Air (M3) 15″ configurations:

    ASUS Vivobook S 15 OLED S5507 configurations:

    Subscribe
    Notify of
    guest
    0 Comments
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments